Category Archives: Politics and Society

What Is Man?

The most important question we can ask about ourselves is, “What is man?” It is not, let me emphasize, “What does it MEAN to be human?”, but “What is a human being?” This is the question asked by the psalmist in Psalm 8 asking of God: What is man that you are mindful of him? This is the essential existential question, the question whose answer answers all other questions about our lives, our religion, our politics, our nationhood. It is THE question.

It is THE question and the one about which we think little. A podcast came across my feed this morning, almost by “accident,” that grabbed my attention. It was a New York Times hitpiece on American evangilicalism and the coming mid-term elections in November. It began as a conversation between two journalists who were raised in the conservative evangelical church but have since become too wise to believe the tenets of Christianity. They delighted in tarring evangelical Christianity with the January 6 riot at the Capitol. Because, they said, some of those storming the barricades were praying and waving about Christian symbols and flags, this is The Handmaids tale come to life. Yes, it was a slander, but it is how the secular view a Christianity that takes its theology and practice seriously, and it is well worth the time to listen and understand.

The second half of the podcast was an interview by the podcast host of Al Mohler – yes, that Al Mohler who is often slandered by the relgious right for being too accomodating of “on the other hand” thinking. But unlike many whom I call brother, I like Al Mohler. He is a thinker, and Christianity demands more than blind submission. God created us to think and to do, and we can’t fulfill our purpose without thinking and doing.

But enough about Al Mohler. The interviewer could not understand how Mohler could say he would not, could not, vote for a Democrat because of that party’s embrace of abortion on demand and the LGBTQ agenda. Are there not, he asked, other issues of great importance, that go beyond those two issues? And this is where I wish Al had used my verbage instead of his. Al answered that the sanctity of life in womb and the institution or marriage are the paramount issues for our time and place.

What he said is true, but what I think would have been a better response would have been, “The question that is before us, and before every person in every place and in every time is this: What is man?”

Why is abortion an issue? Well, “What is man?” If humanity is the product of millennia of evolution, then man is nothing more than a biological accident whose life is of no more value than that of a parmicium. But if man is a creature, a created being, made according to scripture “in the image of God,” an animated by the divine Spirit breathed into him at his creation and having that animation passed from generation to generation through the process of conception and birth, then every human being in every stage of life is special and deserving of special consideration and care. Black lives, indigenous lives, asian lives, white lives, poor lives, rich lives matter because all living are because God created man in his image, male and female he created them.

And that brings Al’s second paramount issue, marriage – what it is, and what it cannot be. The lifelong union of a man and a woman for the purpose of producing the next generation and nurturing those children to become themselves the parents of the next generation is premised on creation and the creation of humanity as male and female. All other expressions of human sexuality and sexual identity reject the notion of creation in the image of God and thus make our very existence meaningless. So, again the question to be answered is, “What is man?”

No other question pressing in upon us is more important than, “What is man?” Having the right answer to that question lays the foundation to address every other question that confronts us. Casting aside the hand of God in creation casts aside the very worth and meaning of being human. Hence, says Al Mohler, having the right and true answer to this question must be THE issue on which a Christian is to vote. To do otherwise is unthinkable.

Beware False Prophets!

Ecclesiastes 12:13–14, The end of the matter; all has been heard. Fear God and keep his commandments, for this is the whole duty of man.] For God will bring every deed into judgment, with every secret thing, whether good or evil. (ESV)

Jeremiah 14:13–14, Then I said: “Ah, Lord GOD, behold, the prophets say to them, ‘You shall not see the sword, nor shall you have famine, but I will give you assured peace in this place.’” And the LORD said to me: “The prophets are prophesying lies in my name. I did not send them, nor did I command them or speak to them. They are prophesying to you a lying vision, worthless divination, and the deceit of their own minds. (ESV)

These two passages were in my morning bible reading. They jumped up and smacked me!

I know that sometimes I come across as a grumpy old man railing against social change. I don’t want to be that guy. So let me say again why I am a Facebook and blogging warrior speaking out against what God declares to be sin.

I do not want to see those who are not fully committed to evil die in their sins. Every human being under heaven is under obligation to know the Creator of the universe and to obey him. Whether you are family or friend or distant stranger in a foreign land, you (and I) will be called before the judgment seat of God to answer for the life you have lived.And the standard of this coming judgment are the universal laws of God revealed in his word. So, yes, I get a little stirred up when the “false prophets” (the politicians, experts, commentators, media darlings, “progressive” pastors, and others) encourage men and women to disregard the law of God and to live their lives as though God is not, and they will enter some state of eternal bliss on death.

So, yes, I am angry at the Joe Bidens and Elon Musks and Madonnas of the world who are encouraging those who think them to be reliable guides to sin without regard to the coming judgment. I believe Joe Biden is the greater sinner than the women he encourages to abort. I believe Elon Musk is the greater sinner with his multiple children with multiple women than the 16 year old young man and his 14 year old girlfriend whose passion is greater than their morals. And I believe all the entertainment types who whore on stage and in life to be greater sinners than those they encourage to copy. I would not shed a tear for them should God strike them dead and usher them into judgment today.

Anyone who tells us we can disregard the commandments of God is a false prophet and a liar whether they be a president or a bishop. I wouldn’t be so angry if I did not know that they will lead many others less evil through the gates of hell. So I rant and rail. And I hope someone listens and repents for why would you want to face the judgment without a savior?

Justice Denied

Where my daily bible reading took me this morning: Deuteronomy 19:15–21

“A single witness shall not suffice against a person for any crime or for any wrong in connection with any offense that he has committed. Only on the evidence of two witnesses or of three witnesses shall a charge be established. [16] If a malicious witness arises to accuse a person of wrongdoing, [17] then both parties to the dispute shall appear before the LORD, before the priests and the judges who are in office in those days. [18] The judges shall inquire diligently, and if the witness is a false witness and has accused his brother falsely, [19] then you shall do to him as he had meant to do to his brother. So you shall purge the evil from your midst. [20] And the rest shall hear and fear, and shall never again commit any such evil among you. [21] Your eye shall not pity. It shall be life for life, eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot. (ESV)

The American legal system has abandoned the very idea of Justice. There is so much unpunished or wrongly punished crime happening in our communities and we have no recourse to seeking justice when the legal system conspires against it.

Take the Buffalo murderer. Justice would say that he should already have been tried, convicted, and executed. Instead, the legal system celebrates that they have charged him with a plethora of hate and weapons crimes – crimes that will never be appropriately punished. Heaping charges on a criminal does not punish him, it only makes the chargers feel virtuous.

The bible tells us we must execute murderers if we would preserve society. It further tells us that a major restraint against false convictions and executions is to punish a false witness with the punishment appropriate to the crime. If a person is falsely accused of murder, then the prosecutor or policeman or nextdoor neighbor should be tried and executed for murdering an innocent man.

Justice goes crying in our cities and the blood of the murdered cries out from the ground.

When She Dies, It Will Come?

Watching some of the jubilee celebration of the 70 years of Elizabeth’s reign there in London and seeing that longest-reigning monarch standing on her balcony receiving honors from her people, I could not but think of Methuselah, the longest-lived man recorded in scripture.

According to the biblical record, Methuselah lived 969 years and died in the year God sent the Flood to wash the earth clean of the corruption that is humanity. His name means, “Man of the Dart,” or as biblical interpreters prefer, “When he dies, it will be sent.” You can see why the second meaning is preferable in understanding that the man himself was a living prophecy. As his grandson, Noah, labored on the ark, his growing old meant the end was growing near.

Elizabeth’s reign spans one of the most spectacular eras of modern history. It has been a period of incredible technological advance in which the people of our world have enjoyed unprecedented prosperity and peace. But as she draws closer to drawing her last breath, we hear the rumblings of the end of this era of prosperity and peace.

The years of Elizabeth’s reign have also been an era of incredible moral decay. As in the days of Methuselah, the thoughts of man are on nothing but evil continually. During the past 70 years sexual perversion has come out of the closet and is celebrated as liberation from a patriarchal God. Marriage is disparaged. Childbearing and motherhood are thought beneath a modern woman. Manliness is mocked; men are no longer honored as providers and protectors, but are celebrated for being sperm donors instead of fathers. Drug abuse is rampant. Our cities have filled with wastrels, thieves, derelicts, and murderers. The self-murder rate is soaring among the young; children as young as 6 are despairing and taking their own lives.

Will the end of Elizabeth’s reign be a, “It will be sent,” moment? I don’t know. I do know the world hates God as much today as it did when he brought the flood back then. I do know things can only get worse. I do know that God has set a day in which he will judge the world and pronounce humanity guilty of treason. And I do know that the penalty for treason is death.

O wretched man that I am, who can deliver me from this world’s certain future destruction? Thanks be to God! He has sent his Son into this world to rescue all who believe on his name. When the fires of God’s judgment falls on this rebel planet, there is safety and security in Jesus. As it is written, the righteous run into the LORD and are safe.

Is A Preference for Our Founding Philosophy White Supremacy?

There was a tragic racially motivated massacre Saturday (May 14) in Buffalo, New York. A young man, whether he is demon-possessed, mentally ill, or miseducated, I do not know, entered a supermarket with the intent to kill as many black people as he could. Suffice it to say that what he did represents the opinions or views of the tiniest of tiny minorities in this country who are terrified and believe race or ethnicity is the defining feature of what it is to be American. This view is no more representative of America’s European majority than Louis Farrakhan’s racist rantings are representative of America’s African minority, and we can’t let the race hustlers of any ethnicity gaslight the nation into believing America is a nation founded on notions of race. It simply isn’t true. Of all the nations on this planet, ours is the one most committed to the view that the content of the mind, the philosophical and religious underpinnings, the family and the home are what makes America and not the geographic and ethnic origins of its populace. 

Christianity, and protestant Christianity especially, is America’s foundational philosophy. We find this philosophy laid out in Ephesians chapter 2. Paul, in addressing the ethnic and cultural divisions that plagued his time and place, tells the gentiles of Ephesus that Christ had broken down the wall of separation between Jew and Gentile and made these new Christians one Church by his death on the cross. What we have little understanding of today given the weakness of our public education system is how fractious Europe was during the time of the migration of our founders to this continent. 

Just to take the British Isles as an example, the native population (not those of Asian or African ethnicity) see themselves even today as English and Welsh and Scottish and Irish and Cornish and any number of other regional ethnicities rather than just British and it was yet more true at the time of our founding. In 1700, Scotland was a separate kingdom from England, and these two peoples did not see themselves as one at all. Our founding called upon these Europeans to see themselves as One People united around the central tenets of our Christian and Western European heritage and not their places of origin, just as the Church was one new people made up of peoples from every ethnicity and language centered on Christ. 

Sometime after our great Civil War (1861-65), America slipped off its foundation. Biblical Christianity was replaced by progressivism in the mainline churches and in secular society. The 20th Century, with its wars and revolutions, saw America abandon its founding principles for a worldview that considers every thought equal and nothing eternal. We abandoned the collective quest for the Good, the True, and the Beautiful, for the exaltation of the individual and individual thought and expression. While it’s easy for those who think like me to point to the rise of feminism, homosexual celebration, and abortion as markers of American collapse, it is more important to point out that it is the abandonment of the simple truth that God IS which lies at the base of our national decline. With no pesky god telling us what is Good or True or Beautiful, we have been set free to come up with our own definitions and practices, and inevitably those practices don’t work very well. 

White (or Black) Supremacy is one of those beliefs that don’t work well. It is a belief built on a vapor. The color of the skin says nothing about the condition of the heart and mind, but the idea of ethnic superiority is as old as humanity itself. The natural default position is us against them. Are you with me or are you against me? That is The Question. The Christian concept of the creation of a new humanity that spans all tribal and ethnic identities unites us on universal principles. Once honest Christianity is abandoned, we revert quite naturally to our old tribalism. 

Consequent to America’s rejection of unity on a common identity, it has embraced a concept of pluralism in which every philosophical/religious/ethnic identity is encouraged in the name of diversity. The problem is that diversity doesn’t work. For a nation to remain one, it must have a common identity. Multiple identities, like multiple personality disorder, is an illness not an advantage. A hyphenated America is a disordered America. This is not to say that every immigrant must surrender his prior identity, but he must embrace the founding principles of the republic and see himself as fully American with no loyalties to any other governmental or social principles. Enrich the existing culture while embracing the founding principle of “out of many one” – the principle of Ephesians 2. 

So to answer the question that heads this epistle, the answer is, No. Ethnic supremacy, be it white, or black, or Chinese, or Japanese, or whatever is a denial of our founding and the instrument of national suicide. The walls of separation must be torn down from both sides, from the majority and from the minorities and our oneness celebrated. 

On the USS George Washington Suicides

Before I speak to the issue, the young people on this ship are no different than the youth on the street or in our colleges. I do not place the entire blame for their deaths on their shoulders. America’s suicide crisis – and the military’s – has been a long time coming and will continue to fester into the foreseeable future. 

I have some understanding of a sailor’s life during overhaul. I joined the USS Darter in 1966 while she was having a major overhaul in the Charleston Naval Shipyard. I know what it’s like to stand fire watches late into the night and early before the morning dawns as welders weld and shipfitters fit. I was young, dumb, and a 19-year-old petty officer 3rd class fresh out of sonar school – and a non-qual at that! (My fellow submariners will understand that note.). That Navy wasn’t the kinder, gentler Navy of today, and nobody expected to be treated with anything other than “do your duty!”. I was a cog in the machine and expected to be nothing more. I was loaned out to two other boats in the squadron which were deploying on operations and were short sonarmen with my skill identifier. (USS Amberjack and USS Trumpetfish) So not only was I new to my boat, but I was a stranger in a strange land as a hired gun on these boats. I say this to make the point that I’ve been there, done that, and have the t-shirt. 

These military suicides are not because of “toxic command climate” although the mob will clammer for the heads of the Captain, the XO, and the Command Master Chief. It is easier to lay the blame on them rather than face the underlying causes. Now I’m not going to say the leadership is perfect. They after all were raised by the same culture/society that produces these youth who are unable to withstand the trials of the life they have made for themselves. 

I participated in a US Pacific Command suicide prevention seminar at Fort Shafter, Hawaii, back in 2009. After asking what they would see as an acceptable suicide rate – and being told it should be zero – I said to the disapproving murmurs of my small group that we would look back to the suicide numbers of 2009 and marvel that they were so low. I was right, and the group think was wrong. The bandaid of social workers and mental health professionals that we have applied to our schools, and military units have done nothing to treat the causes of the thinking that makes suicide an option to life. 

I’ll let someone else write the book on this subject, but here’s a brief sketch of the causes of military suicide as I see it. 

  1. The scourge of feminism. Feminism is the mother of abortion, homosexuality and transgenderism, divorce and polygamy, and the feminization of the American male. Those bearded gym rats with their six-packs and tattoos are sham men. They are pretty boys who preen before the mirror, but they have no understanding of what it means to be a man who will do his duty though the heavens fall. They will spend thousands on cars and “lifestyle” but are unwilling to commit to marriage, family, and the duty of citizenship in the community. So, feminism has given us several generations now of fake men who do not know the joy of being a man and who crumble under the load that genuine manhood brings. They can press their body weight, but they can’t carry a family for a lifetime. In addition, feminism has given us women who do not want to be a complement to a husband. The American woman wants to compete with men, and as the recent kerfuffle over men competing in women’s sports has demonstrated, they cannot do “man things” as well as men can, and this gives them added stress. 
  1. The military was uniquely suited to turn boys into men. I was 17 when I enlisted in the Navy, and at 17 the Navy expected me to be a man. I wasn’t a man when I joined, but I quickly grew into what was expected of me. I say, “was,” because the women’s elements of Army, Navy, and Marines were integrated into the all-male military back in the 70s and military standards were weakened to accommodate female sensibilities and capabilities. Women are incredibly strong in their God-given areas. In their arena they can do things that make a strong man shudder, but they are not men without boy parts. Women and men are not interchangeable, yet the American public pretends that they are, and feminist activists demand that we all engage in this charade. In the name of equality, our military, wherever women are integrated, produces weaker men and less capable units. They are weaker because they are not stressed to their full capabilities in their training in order to accommodate the women in the unit – the men have to move slower so the women can keep up. 
  1. America has forfeited its soul. I can’t put my finger on the decade when this forfeiture began, but I can look around and see that it no longer has one. The core of a man, the core of a woman, the core of a nation is a knowledge of God. But we have been raising generations to believe they have no higher authority than their own wishes and desires. “To thine own self be true,” has become the American dream and the result is men without chests (to quote a little C.S. Lewis). A man or a woman who doesn’t acknowledge that there is a God who has ultimate authority to define and declare what is right and what is wrong has no central core to keep them from swaying in the winds of adversity. To semi-quote Dennis Prager, without God you can BELIEVE self-murder is wrong, but you cannot KNOW self-murder is wrong. If there is no absolute authority who stands outside our self-governance, all social guidance is just opinion. In the decline, and decline it is, since America quit worshipping God, our inner core has become a shadow and a memory. And people without a core break easily. 
  1. The church and the nation now accord the same honors to a person who kills himself as to one who dies nobly. This must not be! That sounds harsh I know. Shouldn’t we minister to the sorrowing? But having an honors ceremony for a sailor who has committed suicide encourages other weak souls to follow suit. I may have great concern for the derelict who steals to support herself, but without fear of punishment, crime increases. So it is with suicide. If we do not declare suicide a dishonorable act, we enable future suicides. There was a day not long ago when the church refused burial in the church cemetery to a suicide. Later generations of clergy thought that cruel and opened their arms and graves. But what looked merciful at the moment removed a barrier to the despairing considering suicide and invited them to do likewise. In the same manner with the military, a suicide was a “line of duty, no.” If a service member committed suicide, survivor benefits were not paid to his estate and honors were not rendered. Again, this is harsh, but its abandonment has removed a barrier to choosing a permanent solution to a temporary problem. 
  1. The scourge of social media. The social media to which the young (and not so young) are addicted is awash with affirming suicide as a legitimate life choice. It is glamorized instead of being denigrated, and being treated with sympathy and understanding, it increases its attraction and its occurrence. 
  1. Sex. There is continual competition within the ranks for the sexual favors of the young women – and occasionally, the young men in a unit. That was true in my first mixed gender unit in 1987. It was a shock to see young female privates and specialists new to the unit being pursued. The men acted like a pack of hounds competing over a bitch in heat. And until she would either choose one as her mate of the moment or declare herself a lesbian, she had no peace. All branches of the military have huge bureaucracies dedicated to managing the sexual drives of their members, but adding layers of bureaucracy will never change human nature, and if it does, it only produces eunuchs and whores.

You could, no doubt add to my list if you’re honest about the current state of the American spirit. Suffice it to say that we have a much weaker social fabric and a much weaker military than we once had. This weakened social structure produces people who have no authority higher than their own passions and desires. And those passions and desires can never be fully met by the military or the career or the most recent “fiancé.”  

War Is Hell -acious

John 8:7 – “Let him who is without sin among you be the first to throw a stone at her.” (ESV)

To quote Richard Nixon, “Let me be perfectly clear!” I believe Russia is wrong in its invasion of Ukraine. They were wrong – very wrong. Having said that, when it comes to national sentiment and reportage by the media, it all depends on whose ox is being gored.

What do I mean by that? Somewhere around 1 million Iraqis and Afghans have died due to America’s war making there in the past 30 years. That’s a whole lot of dead men, women, and children, and not counting the widows, orphans, and little boys and girls sold into sexual slavery because of the deep poverty into which they were thrust.

But here’s the thing: I cheered when American forces destroyed hundreds of Iraqi tanks and other combat vehicles on the Highway of Death in the 1st gulf war – along with the thousands of Iraqi conscripts who perished in their vehicles. And I cheered just as loudly when the air campaign began during the 2nd and we leveled sections of Baghdad. and when we leveled Mosul in order to save it later on in the war.

In Afghanistan we overthrew the legitimate government of the nation and installed a puppet regime more to our liking and less to the liking of the Afghan people – and over the years killed over 200,000 Afghans in the process.

All this to say I’m more than just a little uneasy watching this current war play out on our screens. It’s not that I want the Russians to succeed – I don’t. I want them to return to their borders and cease this wanton destruction of Ukrainian cities and infrastructure, and the senseless devastation of the civilian populace. (And I don’t like seeing soldiers die either!) No, it’s that war is a horror. It’s never clean. Killing is never surgical. Cities are chokepoints and you destroy them and everyone in them. And our hands are not clean and we shouldn’t pretend that they are.

Putin’s “reason” for this war is almost the same as ours in Iraq and Afghanistan (and Vietnam too for that matter, but most of you are too young to remember that one.) – the “enemy” was threatening our national interests and intervention was necessary to prevent further damage.

War should always be the option of last resort. It is not always an atrocity, but it is always a horror. Looking at our history over the past 150 years, there are only 2 wars that stand out as necessary from our perspective: World War 2 and Korea. The others, from the Spanish-American to Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan, we got into either through hubris or political expediency – or just bumbled into them. And wars, even those waged from the purest of motives leave death and destruction in their wake requiring a generation or more to recover. America has a generation of soldiers who will carry the physical and mental wounds of war to their graves – and this is not counting the millions in those nations in which we warred who will do the same.

So, Mr. Putin – stop! Withdraw and pay Ukraine for the death and destruction you have caused. And America and her allies – stop pretending your hands are clean and your motives pure; they are not.

When Corporations Promote Perversion

I’ve been asked if I have a biblical foundation for saying that Christians must have nothing to do with Disney and its products while there are many other corporations that have embraced the satanic/anti-God promotion of gender confusion and sexual perversion that I am not saying we should avoid. Yes, I do. 

This passage from Paul’s first letter to the Corinthians provides the principle: (1 Corinthians 5:9–10)  I wrote to you in my letter not to associate with sexually immoral people— not at all meaning the sexually immoral of this world, or the greedy and swindlers, or idolaters, since then you would need to go out of the world. (ESV) 

You say, this passage is talking about sexual immorality within Christ’s family as opposed to that as practiced by outsiders. True. The principle I’m drawing out is exactly that. The world outside the Church is a cesspool which we cannot avoid. It is everywhere! All who have not been born anew into God’s kingdom are members of The Great Rebellion that began as a war by Satan and his associates against the rule of God over his universe. This war that began in heaven drew humanity in as we read in the opening chapters of Genesis and made us rebels as well. But we are not to tolerate the world insinuating itself into our homes and into the minds of our children. 

God created humanity as male and female for us to participate with him in the further creation of the race. The very essence of our humanity is this duality. It is the joining of male and female into a lifelong bond for the creation and development of the next generation (Note that the very word, “generation,” means to cause or make.) that makes us most human and most like the God who made us. This essential value, this most important thing that brings us into partnership with the Creator, then is the point on which The Rebellion focuses its attack. Convince people that their participation in creation is not what most clearly makes them creatures of God and you can enlist them in the rebel cause. 

Corporate America from Adidas to Zillow are participants in The Rebellion – absolutely and without a doubt. They have made it clear that corporate policy is to embrace perversion. The world and all that is within it is at enmity with God and with God’s people. These corporations and those within them who have declared themselves God’s enemies by endorsing what God has condemned and condemning what God has approved will be destroyed in the fire that is to purify this world of sin and sinners. But unlike Disney, they remain outside our families; their products are neutral, neither promoting evil nor restraining right doing. But if they start marketing perversion into our homes and into the minds of our children, then all who are friends of God must cease doing business with them or find themselves joining the enemy and participating in its rebellion and experiencing its punishment. 

  

The Russo-Ukrainian War

Reflections on the Ukrainian War 

I may be a little cynical, but the longer this war in Ukraine is reported upon, the more curious I become on why it is being reported as it is. Those of us of a certain age grew up watching World War 2 play out on our television screens. We watched the replays of the various news outlets and the propaganda films of the War and Navy Departments, and I find myself marveling at the contrast between then and now. 

World War 2 was covered as a clash of armies and of battles on the seas and in the air. December 7th, the American entry into the war, wasn’t reported as an attack on Honolulu or even on Oahu. We saw the Japanese attack on the naval anchorage in Pearl Harbor, the air bases at Hickam and Wheeler, and Army installations at Schofield Barracks and Fort Shafter. There were civilian casualties, but they were collateral damage to the Japanese attack. 

From the German and Soviet invasion of Poland in September 1939 to the surrender of Japan on the deck of the USS Missouri in September 1945, this war was reported as the march of armies and great battles fought from the Russian steppes to the African deserts, battles between great fleets from Midway to the Coral Sea, and air raids over embattled Europe. Seldom were civilians mentioned other that as collateral damage as an incident of the war. 

Seldom, that is, unless those were good guy civilians. The Battle of Britian was shown from the perspective of both the great heroism by the outmanned and out-gunned Royal Air Force, and as the remarkable endurance of the British people as they bore down and endured during the destruction of their cities and homes by the German bombers. The newsreels highlighted the suffering of “our” people in the war even as the destruction of Italian and German and Japanese cities were celebrated. 

Now don’t get me wrong. Just as you can’t make an omelet without cracking eggs, you can’t fight a war without killing civilians along with those in uniform. My sympathies lie with the attacked not the attackers. (Unless, of course, those attackers are “my” attackers. Then the sympathies can get a little confused.) 

All this to bring us to the Russian invasion of Ukraine and how it is being reported. Ukraine has 200,000 active-duty soldiers and another 600,000 or so reservists and veterans of previous conflicts with the Russians. The Russians have been gnawing away at Ukraine since at least 2014 and the Ukrainian military is well-versed in Russian military tactics and how to counter them. Ukraine is not a helpless child whimpering in the corner. These are tough people used to tough times and they have a long memory of Stalin’s starving to death of some 2 million of them during the 1930s (a fact the New York Times denied at the time and has not corrected since) to bring those Ukrainian peasants into submission to his socialist ideals. But this is not how this war is being reported. Correct me if I’m not seeing everything, but I’ve not seen one Ukrainian general or colonel speaking to their victories in the reports by the major media outlets. I’ve not seen a single graphic showing how the Ukrainian army is deploying to counter the Russians nor how the use of American and European weaponry is being used by them to great result. 

Now we know the Ukrainians are enjoying success on the battlefield. Russian units are being decimated. But if we only knew what the media is showing us, these successes are by Molotov cocktail-throwing grandmothers defending their homes and shops, and not by well-armed and well-trained professional soldiers defending their homeland. This war is being reported as a war on civilians resisted by civilians, and the question is, “Why?” 

Fleeing women and crying children make good video. It is easy enough to pluck the heartstrings by showing a bloodied woman clutching her wounded child, or to show them in refugee encampments in Poland and elsewhere standing in soup lines and weeping over not knowing what tomorrow will hold. It makes good video, but poor understanding about how the war is being waged from the Ukrainian side. Watching 30 minutes of reporting by PBS or CBS or NBC (Russell Holt is on the ground in Poland with Mr. Biden and I cannot understand why he is the only person in the shot wearing a mask – but that’s a rant for another day!) or the BBC or DW or any of the other “news” organizations will give us tears but no understanding. How is the war progressing from an operational or strategic perspective? We have no way of knowing from their reporting. We know some Ukrainian cities are being reduced to rubble, but no one is pointing out that can be a really bad idea from the attackers’ perspective. Rubble makes great defensive positions. 

So we have a fairly good picture of the civilian dislocation caused by the Russian invasion but no picture at all of how Ukrainian defenses are holding. And this, now I get to my point, is the strategy behind the reporting/propaganda effort. We hate Russia. We’ve hated Russia since the 1918 Communist Revolution. We even hated them when they were our allies during WW2 – that alliance was a marriage of convenience not of shared values. We hated them during the communist uprising in Greece, the Berlin Airlift, the Korean War (Russian pilots were flying missions for the Norks), the Vietnam War, and the entire Cold War. And our ancestors hated Russia long before our hating began. Russia has been a contender for European dominance since at least Peter the Great (in other words, since before the United States were even a twinkle in the eye of our founders’ fathers) and our European ancestors weren’t about to surrender their grip on power. So, we hated Russia yesterday; we hate Russia today; and we’ll hate Russia tomorrow. And by “we” I mean those who hold the reins of power and influence. 

Wars take time and consume resources that might be better used in other endeavors. And people, especially the American people who are entertaining themselves to death with Tik-Tok videos, have a very short attention span. (Most will find this essay too long to hold their attention.) How do you get them to stay engaged – to stay engaged and be willing to lower their standard of living to pursue the war? By highlighting helpless women and children. I’ve railed against our feminized culture and political landscape elsewhere and I need not pursue it further other than to say that the way to keep American women focused on what you want them to see, is to show them how a terrible man (Vladimir Putin) is making women and children suffer. (He probably tortures cats too!) 

Pershing said Infantry wins battles, but logistics wins wars. Wars are fought on three levels: the tactical, the operational, and the strategic. The tactical is led by captains and non-commissioned officers. The operational is led by commanders of battalions, brigades, and divisions. The strategic (from the American military perspective) is led by the highest ranks of the flag officers and their civilian overseers at the Department of Defense, the State Department, and the White House. Captains fight skirmishes: colonels fight battles; generals fight campaigns; politicians fight wars. And the news front is part of the war effort. 

The newsreels of WW2 were propaganda videos. They presented the war effort in a way to keep the populace motivated to continue the war in the face of shortages by showing them great campaign victories and highlighting the evil intent of the enemy (which wasn’t hard given the evil that had seized Germany with the rise of the National Socialists). Much of the rationing that was imposed on the populace and the rubber and metal collection campaigns were designed to let the people feel they were participating in the war effort even when little of it was needed in much the same way as the government’s Covid restrictions were designed to control the people and not the virus (which is far more difficult if not impossible to control). 

So, today’s video from the front is not intended to inform, but to control and motivate. I’m not saying that it is out of evil intent by government and media, but it is manipulation not information, and Caveat Emptor.  

On the Russo-Ukrainian War

I will not lie; my sympathies lie with the Ukrainian people. Russia does have some legitimate complaints about how the United States and its European client states through NATO have encroached into what Russia considered its area of interest after the collapse of the Soviet Union, but that in no wise justifies the Russian assault on the Ukrainian people. However, the American/European response lies open to question as well. Here are a few observations from an old man. 

  1. Ukraine, as a nation, has only existed for 40 years while Ukrainians, as a people, have been one of the many tribes/ethnicities that make up Europe for at least 1000 years and probably much longer. Europe is a mishmash of tribes and languages not unlike the rest of the world even though it pretends to be above such things. Well, Ukrainians are one of those tribes even though they have been included within other nations and empires since the collapse of the Kievan Russ a thousand years ago. Nation status and ethnic identity are two different things, and a little observation of human history tells us that identity is stronger than statehood. So, although Mr. Putin wants to absorb the Ukrainian people into the Russian people, as long as Ukrainians identify themselves as a distinct people, that will be a failed enterprise regardless Russia’s military success. 
  1. We all love “David and Goliath” stories regardless the fact that the first one was not a recitation of the little guy defeating the big guy but rather the continuing story of God’s care for his elect. History tells us that the big guy almost always wins and that the more resistance the little guy puts up, the greater his injury in his defeat. Given that, the US/European encouragement for the Ukrainians to put up a good fight against the Russians before they go down in defeat will only cause greater death, injury, and destruction for the Ukrainians. Yes, they may bloody the Russians, but unless we are seriously overestimating Russian military capabilities, the Russians will win in the end. That is, they’ll win unless they lose the will to fight to the end as did the United States in Iraq and Afghanistan (two other ill-conceived invasions of sovereign states). 
  1. So, is the West acting in the interests of the Ukrainian people when they send arms and ammunition to the Ukrainian government that they might continue their resistance to the invasion? Who benefits from the US paying Poland to send Ukraine MiG fighters? It will prolong the fight, no doubt. But is a prolonged fight in the interest of the Ukrainian people? You know my answer: the Ukrainian people are best served by their government coming to an agreement with the Russian government and restoring the peace. Yes, the Ukrainian government may need to retreat from their push to join the European Union and the NATO military alliance in this generation. Yes, they may need to keep themselves within the Russian sphere of influence. But spheres of influence and military alliances aren’t forever, and what’s a generation or two in the history of a people whose story spans millennia? 
  1. Who then is benefiting from the US and her client states encouraging the Ukrainian government in its resistance? As I watch the price of gasoline and diesel soaring at the pump here, my first candidates are the major oil-producing nations and regions: The United States (#1), the Persian Gulf states (#3), and Russia (#2). Yes, Russia. Their oil isn’t going to magically disappear if it is not pumped to Germany and the other EU countries tomorrow. The US may embargo Russian oil, but that embargo won’t last long, and Russia will soon be able to pump away and at a much higher price. So, the #1 beneficiary of this conflict are the oil producing states and their energy corporations. Next are the weapons manufacturing countries and industries, and again the United States takes the lead with our client states and Russia again following in our train. Boeing, Lockheed Martin, Northrop Grumman, Raytheon, and many other smaller corporations will be making bank off this conflict for decades to come. Those Polish MiGs must be replaced, and they will be replaced with more expensive, more technologically advanced aircraft from the United States. And less I forget, Ukraine is a large market for Western products and a major producer of foodstuffs. The only people I don’t see benefiting from this conflict are the Ukrainians themselves. They are the ones who will pay and continue to pay for generations to come. 

So, pray for peace in Ukraine. Pray intelligently. And be just a little cynical about the purity of national interests on every side.